When a Customer Says "We Can't Pay Right Now"
Short answer: thank the customer for telling you, ask what they can pay and on what date, put the plan in writing, check in before each installment, and pause standard reminders on that account while the plan runs.
When a customer says "we can't pay right now," the next message matters more than the last five.
A few things that protect both the balance and the relationship:
- Thank them for telling you. Silence is the harder problem, and you want them to keep talking.
- Ask what they can pay and when, not whether. A smaller payment on a fixed date beats a vague promise to catch up.
- Put the plan in writing: amounts, dates, and what happens with new orders in the meantime.
- Check in a few days before each installment, the same way you would before a due date.
- Pull that account out of your standard reminder sequence. A templated "your invoice is overdue" in the middle of a plan undoes the goodwill.
What a good first reply sounds like
"Thanks for letting me know, I appreciate the heads-up. Could you tell me what you can pay now and when the rest might be possible? If we can agree on a few dates, I'll put them in writing and pause our automatic reminders while the plan is running."
Setting up the plan in your accounting system
- QuickBooks Online: record each installment against the specific invoice with Receive Payment, note the plan on the customer, and turn off automatic reminders for that customer while it runs.
- NetSuite: log the plan on the customer record, set follow-up tasks for each installment date, and keep the customer out of scheduled collection emails.
- Xero: turn off invoice reminders for that contact and add the agreed dates to the invoice history or an expected payment date, so the Aged Receivables report reads correctly.
- Sage: add a note or memo on the account with each installment date, and hold statements or reminders until the plan finishes or a date is missed.
- Microsoft Dynamics 365 Business Central: change the customer's reminder term while the plan is active, and track installments against the open entries.
If an installment date passes without payment, call that day. A missed date on an agreed plan is the clearest signal you will get.
In Nectivo, Amber reads hardship notes on an account and softens the tone of the outreach it drafts. Every AI-drafted email is labeled as AI. Nectivo.ai syncs directly with QuickBooks Online. Teams on NetSuite, Xero, Sage, Microsoft Dynamics or another accounting system can upload an AR aging report export as a CSV or Excel file and work from the same daily list.
Frequently asked questions
Should I offer a payment plan to a customer who can't pay?
Often, yes. A smaller amount on a fixed date usually recovers more than a vague promise to catch up. Agree the amounts and dates in writing, and decide what happens with new orders in the meantime.
Should I keep sending automated reminders during a payment plan?
No. Pause the standard reminders on that account. A templated past-due notice in the middle of an agreed plan undoes the goodwill. Send a short check-in a few days before each installment instead.
What if the customer misses a payment plan installment?
Call promptly and reference the plan: ask what changed and agree a new date. A second missed installment is the point to revisit terms, new orders or a credit hold.
Related: QuickBooks collections software · Free DSO calculator · Pricing